|
Radiant Barriers
Science Vs Hype
By
Ron Birrell
Integrity Energy Systems, Inc.
"...conduction, radiation and
convection are the primary mechanisms of heat transfer in a structure."
---Department of Energy
Convection - or transfer of heat through air
Hot air transfers heat to surrounding
material (rafters, ducting, insulation) heating the attic space thereby
effecting the living space.
The Answer - Soffit and ridge vents.
Conduction - or transfer of heat through material
Hot roof transfers heat from the
surface of the shingles through the material to the underside of the
roof heating the attic space or through the insulation, thereby
effecting the living space.
The Answer – Batts or blown insulation.
Radiation - or transfer of heat through electromagnetic (i.e.
radio) waves
Radiant energy transfers through
space in straight lines until it absorbed (causing heat) by rafters,
ducting, insulation, and on into the living space.
The Answer – Radiant barrier.

Radiant Energy
What is Radiant Energy?
The energy transported by
electromagnetic radiation.
Radiant energy is commonly called light energy. But light energy is
only one kind of radiant energy. All waves emit energy. Radio and
television waves are other types of radiant energy. So are micro waves
and x-rays. Light waves do work by wiggling the receptors in the back
of our eyes.
When this radiation hits an object in it's path, then it may get
absorbed partly or completely and transformed into some other form. For
example, when you are standing in front of a fire, the heat you feel is
transmitted by thermal radiation. Heat will move by radiation even in a
vacuum, as the sun’s heat is transmitted to earth through space.
What Does Radiant Energy Do?
When radiant heat is viewed as a form
of energy, a wave length, rather than a type of heat movement, it
becomes easier to understand how it behaves with fibrous insulation
products. The radiant energy from the sun travels through the roof,
insulation, and into the living space. Depending on how much gets
absorbed by the particular materials will result in the amount of heat
generated.
When radiant heat can be reduces from entering a home, conductive and
convection also decreases proportionately. Therefore, if you can reduce
the amount of radiant energy, you reduce convective and conductive heat
loads which increase comfort and significantly reduces the need for
energy.
Reducing radiant heat can be accomplished by placing one or more highly
reflective surfaces between the space being cooled (your home), and the
source (the sun or you ceiling during the winter). Keep this in mind:
Heat always moves from a higher temperature to a lower temperature.

Radiant Heat Facts:
- Studies have
demonstrated that 75 to 94 percent of the heat gain is from radiant
energy.
- Radiant heat
travels in a straight line from the source (the sun for instance),
to the absorber (the roof and walls of our homes and offices).
- Radiant heat
travels at 186,000 miles per second (speed of light)
- Radiant heat
can only be absorbed or reflected. The amount of which is determined
by the surface it is striking, angle to the source and absorbtivity
of the surface.
- Radiant heat
strikes the earth, our homes, our cars, etc., which in turn heats
the air. A good example of this is our changing seasons. Even though
the sun is much closer to the earth during the winter, the angle at
which radiant heat strikes the earth is a lower angle which bounces;
much of this radiant heat back into space.
Why Doesn’t More Insulation Work?
The “R” Value.
The R-value of Conventional fibrous
batt and blown insulation is a laboratory measurement that does not
consider all 3 methods of heat transfer, only measures resistance to
conduction. Basically, the higher the R factor, the slower heat travels
through it
Effect of Radiant Energy on Insulation.
Insulation absorbs radiant energy,
thereby heating up the insulation. Since insulation has an R factor,
heat gets trapped for many hours in the insulation against the ceiling
creating a demand for cooling energy many hours after the sun has gone
down. You can see this by going into your attic several hours after
sunset. Notice the attic is still hot! Where is the heat coming from?
Now feel the insulation...it's warm.
Without protection from radiant heat, insulation traps, stores, then
releases heat for hours consuming energy, reducing comfort, costing you
energy dollars.
Radiant Barrier
What is a Radiant Barrier!
A radiant barrier is a highly
reflective surface that easily changes the direction of infrared heat
instead of having it absorbed into your insulation. Why slow heat down
in your home or office when you can change the direction with a low
cost, proven, high performance Radiant Barrier? The performance is
unmatched and comfort and savings are immediate.
Scientific Studies on the
Benefit of Radiant Barrier.
Texas A&M University, Nevada
Power Company,
Florida Solar Energy, Northeastern Illinois University,
TennesseeValley Authority, University of Mississippi,
The Oak Ridge National Laboratory,
All conducted studies on radiant
barrier systems. All found conclusively that radiant barriers help keep
cooling energy costs down.See attachment
If Radiant Barriers are so great, where
are they used?
All over the US and in Canada
California and Florida mandate Radiant Barrier for new construction.
Definitions.
Emissivity
- how much heat is emitted from a material.
Aluminum has a very low emissivity, meaning very little heat is radiated
from its surface.
Reflectivity - how much energy is reflected, not
absorbed by a surface.
Aluminum has a high reflectivity.
The lower the emissivity of a surface, the higher its reflectivity
and the more energy efficient it is.See attachment for addition ratings
Radiant Barrier Products
Product Comparisons
There are several radiant barrier
building materials on the market. These products should be carefully
evaluated based on emissivity, ease of handling, installation,
durability, and cost
-
Foil-faced plywood or Oriented Strand Board (OSB)
roof sheathing is installed like ordinary roof sheathing with the
foil layer facing the interior of the attic. Product should be
incised, this allows the sheathing to "exhale" moisture through the
aluminum face
- Single
or double-sided foil
is either draped over trusses before the roof deck is installed or
attached to the underside of trusses or sometimes installed over
standard insulation on the attic floor. The foil is reinforced with
various materials to compensate for its tendency to tear easily, but
care must be taken not to puncture or tear the foil during
installation and routine attic maintenance. Dust build-up on the
surface of the foil increases emissivity and reduces effectiveness.
-
Foil-faced insulation and blown-in foil chips
are used on attic floors where dust buildup on the reflective
surface increases emissivity and reduces effectiveness.
-
Radiant Barrier paint
is designed to be applied to the underside of roof decks or roof
tops. It goes on like an ordinary latex paint (brush, roller or
spray). Last the life of the roof deck when installed on the
underside. No dust buildup, therefore, emissivity and effectiveness
remain the same. Can be sprayed into areas unreachable with foil
blankets.
|
Product |
Material |
Emissivity |
Base |
Cost |
|
Radiosity 3000® |
Paint additive |
NOT RATED |
Borosilicate Glass Beads |
$50/ to mix with 5 gallons of paint |
|
Lo/Mit™I* |
Paint |
.20 |
Xylene |
35 - 65¢ per sq. ft. installed |
|
Lo/Mit™II* |
Paint |
.20 |
DI Water |
35 - 65¢ per sq. ft. installed |
|
Radiance™* |
Paint |
.25 |
|
89¢ per sq. ft.installed |
|
Radiance™* |
Paint |
.49 |
Zinc Silfide |
$45/gal coverage 250 sq. ft. |
|
E-Barrier™ |
Paint |
.32 |
Vinyl Acetate-Ethylene Copolymer |
$55/gal coverage 350-400 sq.ft. |
|
Techshield™ |
Foil bonded to OSB |
.03 |
Aluminum |
13¢ Sq. ft. over the OSB |
|
ELK Echotherm™ |
Foil |
.03** |
(Aluminum) |
37¢ Sq. Ft. |
|
K-Shield™ |
Foil |
.03** |
(Aluminum) |
$1.50 Sq. Ft. |
|
*Only
installed Professionally **Based upon standard ratings for
Aluminum Foil, Product not tested. |
Radiant Barrier Ratings
The radiant barrier should have an
Emissivity Rating.This is the efficiency value calculated or the result
of testing. Testing should be done by a third party laboratory to either
testing standard ASTM E-424-71 or ASTM E903-96 or using a Solar Spectrum
Reflectometer.
The radiant barrier should be an Energy Star Product. ENERGY STAR is the
symbol for energy efficiency, as designated by the U.S. Department of
Energy (DOE) and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).
The radiant barrier should conforms to at least one of the follow as
well as any applicable safety standards;
ASTM C 1313-00 Standard Specification for Sheet Radiant Barriers for
Building Construction Applications
ASTM C 1158-01 Standard Practice for use and Installation of Radiant
Barrier Systems (RBS) in Building Construction
ASTM C 1321-98 Standard Practice for use and Installation of Radiation
Control Coating Systems (IRCCS) in Building Construction“American
Society for Testing and Materials”
|